|
|
|
 Electronic catalog NSAL NAAS online
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 10 |
«UKRAINIAN CAUSE» IN POLISH POLITICAL THOUGHT AFTER WORLD WAR I
|
full article |
|
doi.org/10.31073/istnauka202402-10
PYLYPENKO L.
|
Pages: |
175-198 |
 |
 |
| Summary |
|
The primary objective of this article is to comprehensively explore the evolution of the Polish political thought throughout the transformative years after World War I.
A novel analysis of the diverse perspectives within Polish political thought on the Ukrainian nationalist movement during the interwar period is provided. It highlights the spectrum of views ranging from military confrontation to political integration and emphasizes the influence of broader ideological currents such as nationalism, socialism, and liberalism. Additionally, it situates these debates within the international context of relations with Russia and Germany, offering a fresh perspective on the complexities of Polish-Ukrainian relations in the interwar period. The methodology employed in this study involves a comprehensive review and analysis of historical documents, political writings, and secondary literature. This approach allows for a detailed examination of the ideological debates within Polish political circles and their practical implications for Polish-Ukrainian relations. The study also employs a comparative analysis to contextualize Polish political thought within broader European geopolitical dynamics. The article investigates and clarifies the multifaceted nature of Polish political thought on the Ukrainian issue. It finds that Polish political perspectives ranged from viewing the Ukrainian nationalist movement as a direct threat to advocating for cooperation and cultural autonomy. The study elucidates how these differing viewpoints influenced Polish policies and attitudes towards Ukraine, and how they intersected with broader ideological and geopolitical considerations. The article also underscores the critical role of international relations, particularly with Russia and Germany, in shaping these debates and policies. By shedding light on these dynamics, the article contributes to a deeper understanding of the historical complexities of Polish-Ukrainian relations and the broader context of Eastern European political thought in the interwar period.
|
| Keywords |
|
Polish-Ukrainian relations, diplomacy, the Second Polish Commonwealth, interwar period, UPR, WUPR.
|
| References |
|
- Chojnowski, A. (1979). Koncepcje polityki narodowościowej rządów polskich w latach 1921 – 1939. Wrocław: Zakład Narodowy im. Ossolińskich. 262.
- Dmowski, R. (1926). Polityka polska i odbudowanie państwa. Warszawa 496.
- Dmowski, R. (1947). Polityka polska i odbudowanie państwa. Z dodaniem memoriału «Zagadnienia środkowo- i wschodnio-europejskie» i innych dokumentów polityki polskiej z lat 1914–1919 (Vol. 1). Hannover. 258.
- Litwin, H. (2016). Central European Superpower. BUM Magazine, 26-29.
- Mackinder, H. (1944). Democratic Ideals and Reality. A Study in the Politics of Reconstruction. New-York. 213.
- Nowak-Kiełbikowa, M. (1999). Początki krajowej służby dyplomatycznej. In A. Ajnenkiel (Ed.), Rok 1918. Odrodzona Polska w nowej Europie (pp. 33, 36). Warszawa: NERITON, Instytut Historii PAN. 220.
- Polacy na Ukrainie. Zb. dokumentów. Przemysl, 1998. T. 1. Cz. 1. 248.
- Aleksiyevets, L. (2006). Pol'shcha: utverdzhennya nezalezhnoyi derzhavy 1918-1926 [Poland: establishment of an independent state 1918-1926]. Ternopil: Pidruchnyky i posibnyky. 448 [In Ukrainian].
- Verstyuk, V. (Ed.) (2006). Dyrektoriya, Rada narodnykh ministriv Ukrayins'koyi Narodnoyi Respubliky 1918–1920. Dokumenty i materialy u 2-kh t. [Directory, Council of People's Ministers of the Ukrainian People's Republic 1918–1920. Documents and materials in 2 volumes] (Vol. 2). Kyiv: Vydavnytstvo imeni Oleny Telihy. 744 [In Ukrainian].
- Dornik, V. (2015). Ukrayina mizh samovyznachennyam ta okupatsiyeyu: 1917-1922 roky [Ukraine between self-determination and occupation: 1917-1922] (V. Kam'yanets, Trans.). Kyiv: Nika-Tsentr. 512 [In Ukrainian].
- Zarets'ka, T. (2007). Yuzef Pilsuds'kyy i Ukrayina [Józef Pilsudskyi and Ukraine]. Kyiv. 288 [In Ukrainian].
- Zashkil'nyak, L., & Krykun, M. (2002). Istoriya Pol'shchi: Vid naydavnishykh chasiv do nashykh dniv [History of Poland: From the earliest times to the present day]. Lviv. 752 [In Ukrainian].
- Kozhen'ovs'kyy, M. (2015). Za Zolotymy vorit'my. Suspil'no-kul'turna diyal'nist' polyakiv u Kyyevi v 1905–1920 rokakh [Behind the Golden Gate. Socio-cultural activity of Poles in Kyiv in 1905–1920]. Kyiv: Dukh i Litera. 650 [In Ukrainian].
- Krasivs'kyy, O. (2008). Ukrayins'ko-pol's'ki vzayemyny v 1917-1923 rr. [Ukrainian-Polish relations in 1917-1923]. Kyiv. 540 [In Ukrainian].
- Levyts'kyy, K. (1968). Velykyy zryv [A big disruption]. New-York: Vyd-vo Chartoryys'kykh. 149 [In Ukrainian].
- Lypovets'kyy, S. (2018). Mech «shcherbets'« ta Ukrayins'ki vorota: ukrayino-pol's'ki vzayemyny vid podiliv Rechi Pospolytoyi y do s'ohodni [The Shcherbets sword and the Ukrainian gate: Ukrainian-Polish relations from the time of the partition of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth to today]. Kyiv: Tempora. 473 [In Ukrainian].
- Lytvyn, M. (2015). Proekt «Ukrayina». Halychyna v Ukrayins'kiy revolyutsiyi 1917–1921 rr. [Project «Ukraine». Galicia in the Ukrainian Revolution of 1917–1921]. Kharkiv. 380 [In Ukrainian].
- Lytvyn, M., & Naumenko, K. (1995). Istoriya ZUNR [History of WUPR]. Lviv. 368 [In Ukrainian].
- Lozyns'kyy, M. (1970). Halychyna v rr. 1918–1920 [Galicia in 1918–1920]. New-York. 288 [In Ukrainian].
- Los', Ya. (2018). Ukrayins'ka sprava u spohadakh, lystuvanni y publitsystytsi [The Ukrainian affair in memoirs, correspondence and journalism]. Kyiv: Nika-Tsentr. 340 [In Ukrainian].
- Makarenko, O. (1970). Ukrayina i zarubizhnyy svit [Ukraine and the foreign world]. Kyiv: Politvydav Ukrayiny. 511 [In Ukrainian].
- Makarchuk, S. (1997). Ukrayins'ka respublika halychan: Narysy pro ZUNR [Ukrainian Republic of Galicians: Essays on WUPR]. Lviv. 192 [In Ukrainian].
- Manusevich, A. (1952). Ocherki po istorii Po’lshi [Essays on the history of Poland]. Moskva. 408 [In Russian].
- Mendzhets'kyy, V., & Bratsysevych, Ye. (Eds.). (2015). Pol'shcha – narys istoriyi [Poland – an outline of history]. Warsaw. 365 [In Ukrainian].
- Paliyiv, D. (1929). Lystopadova revolyutsiya. Z moyikh spohadiv [The November Revolution. From my memories]. Lviv: Novyy chas. 44 [In Ukrainian].
- Pyrih, R. (Ed.) (2015). Ukrayins'ka Derzhava (kviten' – hruden' 1918 roku). Dokumenty i materialy. U dvokh tomakh, tr'okh chastynakh [Ukrainian State (April – December 1918). Documents and materials. In two volumes, three parts]. (Vol. 2). Kyiv: Tempora. 412 [In Ukrainian].
- Potapenko, M. (2013). Pol's'kyy politykum v Ukrayins'kiy Derzhavi (kviten' – hruden' 1918 r.) [Polish politicians in the Ukrainian State (April – December 1918)]. Problemy vyvchennya istoriyi Ukrayins'koyi revolyutsiyi 1917–1921 rokiv – Problems of studying the history of the Ukrainian revolution of 1917–1921, issue (9), pp. 101-112 [In Ukrainian].
- Reyent, O. (2004). Ukrayina mizh svitovymy viynamy (1914-1939). Podiyi. Lyudy. Dokumenty: Narysy istoriyi [Ukraine between the world wars (1914-1939). Events People. Documents: Essays of history]. Kyiv: Shkola. 544 [In Ukrainian].
- Smoliy, V. (Ed.) (2001). Narysy z istoriyi dyplomatiyi Ukrayiny [Essays on the history of diplomacy of Ukraine]. Kyiv: Al'ternatyvy. 736 [In Ukrainian].
- Smoliy, V. A., Verstyuk, V. F., Hamrets'kyy, Yu. M., Ivanenko, B. V., Kondufor, Yu. Yu., Kul'chyts'kyy, S. V., & Yakovlyeva, L. V. (Eds.). (1996). Ukrayins'ka Tsentral'na rada: Dokumenty i materialy [Ukrainian Central Council: Documents and materials] (Vol. 1: March 4 – December 9, 1917). Kyyiv: Naukova dumka. 590 [In Ukrainian].
- Smoliy, V. A., Verstyuk, V. F., Hamrets'kyy, Yu. M., Ivanenko, B. V., Kondufor, Yu. Yu., Kul'chyts'kyy, S. V., & Yakovlyeva, L. V. (Eds.). (1997). Ukrayins'ka Tsentral'na rada: Dokumenty i materialy [Ukrainian Central Council: Documents and materials] (Vol. 2: December 10, 1917 – April 29, 1918). Kyyiv: Naukova dumka. 424 [In Ukrainian].
- Stepanyuk, V., & Dovbyshchenko, Ya. (1918). Z istoriyi ukrayins'koho sotsiyal'no-demokratychnoho rukhu (1900-1918 rr.) [From the history of the Ukrainian social democratic movement (1900-1918)]. Kharkiv: Vyd-vo Khark. Kom-tu USDRP. 32 [In Ukrainian].
- Strel's'kyy, H. (2000). Ukrayins'ki dyplomaty doby natsional'no-derzhavnoho vidrodzhennya (1917-1920 rr.) [Ukrainian diplomats of the era of national-state revival (1917-1920)]. Kyiv. 347 [In Ukrainian].
- Tarle, E. (1928). Evropa v epohu imperializma, 1871-1919 gg. [Europe in the Age of Imperialism, 1871-1919.] (2 ed.). Moskva. 511 [In Russian].
- Udovychenko, O. (1995). Ukrayina u viyni za derzhavnist': istoriya orhanizatsiyi i boyovykh diy Ukrayins'kykh Zbroynykh Syl. 1917-1921 [Ukraine in the war for power: the history of the organization and combat operations of the Ukrainian Armed Forces. 1917-1921]. Kyiv. 206 [In Ukrainian].
- Central state archive of higher authorities and management, F. 2592, desc. 1, case 81, page 41 [In Ukrainian].
- Shevchenko, V. (Ed.) (1993). Ukrayins'ki politychni partiyi kintsya XIX – pochatku XX st.: prohramovi i dovidkovi materialy [Ukrainian political parties of the late 19th and early 20th centuries: program and reference materials]. Kyiv: Feniks Konsaltinh. 336 [In Ukrainian].
- Yuzevs'kyy, H. (2017). Zamist' shchodennyka [Instead of a diary]. Lutsk: Vezha-Druk. 168 [In Ukrainian].
- Yarema, Ya. (1997). Nad Syanom. Lystopadovi dni u Peremyshli [Above San. November days in Przemyśl]. Lviv. 96 [In Ukrainian].
|
|
 |
|